Welcome to Key Lime to Happiness Bakery!
Where we are baking up the best Key Lime Pie (and so much more)
Whether you're grabbing a pie bite for yourself or treating a crowd, our signature key lime creations and baked goods are made fresh to order—and always with a sprinkle of happiness.
What is a
PIE BITE?!
All the deliciousness of a full sized pie packed into a cupcake sized pie! Our pie bites are truly pies, they are the same recipes as our full pies, just a smaller version. With their crust on the bottom and wrapped pretty in a cupcake wrapper, they are the perfect personal sized dessert.
Customize your half dozen or dozen box with all the flavors you love.
What our customers are saying:
“Always a must-visit when I’m in town. I have celiac disease and they take great care to avoid cross contamination. They are the kindest people and have the most delicious pies. You won’t regret coming here!”
★★★★★
Madeline G
Believe the hype. These desserts are simply awesome! Key lime pie was the best I have ever had. Can't wait to try some other flavors.
★★★★★
Cindy G.
“Ordered a lot of pies from Key Lime to Happiness for a corporate event and, not only did the pies turn out incredibly delicious, but the customer service was exceptional. The entire staff truly went above and beyond and made the process very smooth. I would definitely order from Key Lime to Happiness again and would recommend it to friends and family.”
★★★★★
Clark W.
The coconut key lime was the best key lime pie I've ever had. The owner was very friendly and helpful.
★★★★★
Michelle W.